fromCONCENTRATE

research blog of artist John O'Shea

Mar 8, 2010 1

Physical Petition

The (symbolic) importance of physically petitioning 10 Downing Street should not be underestimated.

If a citizen takes their petition to 10 Downing Street they are literally and symbolically banging on the ‘front door’ of government and demanding that their issue be given due care and consideration by the highest elected authority in the land.

Our friends, MySociety, facilitate their own online brand of this complaint process; the No 10 Petitions Website – How does this online experience compare?

If you have encountered No 10 Petitions Website it might well have been through receiving an invitation to sign a petition via email (something like) -

Protest the Pope, 10 Downing Street Petition

Petition the Prime Minister, Gordon Brown

Please sign:

http://petitions.number10.gov.uk/ProtestthePope/

And, the Number 10 Petitions Website fosters this kind of signature-gathering-via-email approach, which appears to be a very efficient way to:

  • gauge support for current issues
  • raise the public profile of an issue
  • bring an issue to the attention of central government

When I visited to the site today I noticed that there was a new petition there, campaigning for legislation regarding ‘Mosquito youth deterrent devices.’

http://petitions.number10.gov.uk/MosquitoUse/

The petition was created by Howard Stapleton and reads:

‘We the undersigned petition the Prime Minister to Legislate
the use of the Mosquito device.’

I ’signed’ the petition, (since I strongly disagree with the use of these devices*) and it was pleasingly simple to do so.

Perhaps too simple?  Whilst the online petition is certainly an efficient delivery method, the process feels much more like making a mundane consumer complaint (rather than taking part in an engaged political action).  And that is not the only problem.

The No 10 Petitions Website operates, on one level, on a similar model to the previously mentioned FixMyStreet:

  • “report-the-problem-to-the-relevant-authority Model”

Can reporting a pothole in need of repair (or reporting a broken traffic light in the DIY Democracy example) to a council department REALLY be equated with reporting bigger, less well defined, more complex issues to the Prime Minister?

*These totally unregulated ‘mosquito devices’ send out a high frequency pulsing sound which can only be heard by younger people, indiscriminately targeting them; making their lives unpleasant. The legal use of these devices has not yet been tested in the British Court, but it is widely believed that they are a violation of International Human Rights Law.

Downing Street image file is licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution 2.5 Brazil license.
Original image here: http://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Lula_and_Brown_1_April_2009.jpg

RSS Re-Dock

  • From Fantasy to Reality
    It's over a year now since I first met the group of young people involved in 'Project Triangle'. Looking back, it's easy to see a huge increase in confidence, both from their involvement in the project, and from the work they've done in presenting the film and educational DVD to various groups across the country. On the main, they […]
  • Simple (BIG) Interface
    A couple of weeks ago I took part in DIY Music Day at the World Museum, Liverpool. The event was organised by Ross Dalziel of Sound Network, as part of a series of events called How Why DIY? which aimed to open up technology to a wider audience.This event explored ways in which people could engage with sound, from making their own thumb pianos from simple ma […]
  • Digital Media Labs Award
    Re-Dock are delighted to have been selected for a Digital Media Labs, research and development residency, happening in Hull at the end of October.The residency has been organised as part of the commissioning process for an interactive art work for the new Wilberforce Health Centre in Hull. And, our successful application means that one of us will be spending […]
  • mutate and re-mix!
    "A Small Cinema" has grown beyond our control and, like all great 21st century ideas it has gone VIRAL! We really hoped this day would come (but we hadn't realised that it would be quite so soon!).Tonight a small cinema opens in Oldham, operating out of an empty shop and showing a run of feature films. The project, has been set up by 17 year o […]
  • Gross Indecency
    As a collective, I think all us Re-Dockers are very clear and what is and what is not a Re-Dock project. We've mainly worked this out from our own work practices, where making a living is a major priority. Re-Dock as a CIC can be much more selective. However, it's interesting examining how our work as individuals has grown and been influenced by ou […]
  • The Signs are all there...
    We have just started work on another Re-Dock project involving the Leeds-Liverpool canal. Building on the work we did for Canal &, we are using the memories and ideas gathered as a starting point for a signage installation next to the new Pennington Road bridge.'Constellation Of Signs' will be made of over 100 aluminium road and tourist informa […]